As a global community, we face a choice. Do we want migration to be a source of prosperity and international solidarity, or a byword for inhumanity and social friction?-António Guterres (Portuguese Politician)
Table of Contents
SECTION 1: France's Cultural Chasm: The Genesis of Unrest.
The Spark of French Unrest: The Timeline.
A Traffic Stop to National Unrest: France’s Cultural Divide.
France's Unrest: When Grief Morphs into Rage.
Cultural Chasm and Political Divisions Fuel France's Unrest.
A Presidential Response to France's Unrest.
Global Perspectives on the Unrest in France.
SECTION 2 France and Europe: Immigration Deepening Cultural Chasm and Unrest.
SECTION 3: Triggers of Unrest: Racism & Terror in France & Europe.
SECTION 4: Reflections on France’s Unrest: Key Takeaways.
SECTION 1: France's Cultural Chasm: The Genesis of Unrest
Refusing to stop doesn’t give you a license to kill-Olivier Faure
The Spark of French Unrest: The Timeline
08:00 AM: Two police officers spot a Mercedes with a Polish number plate speeding in a bus lane.
Chase Begins: Ignoring the red light, the car pulls away leading to a pursuit.
08:16 AM: The Mercedes is halted in heavy traffic. Officers draw their guns and approach the car.
The Shooting: As the vehicle moves forward, one officer fires, fatally wounding Nahel in the chest
A Traffic Stop to National Unrest: France’s Cultural Divide
On the morning of June 27, a series of events unfolded in the suburbs of Paris, sending shockwaves across France and the world. Nahel Merzouk, a 17-year-old Algerian descendent, was shot dead by a French police officer in Nanterre at approximately 9 am. As per the police, the boy failed to heed repeated orders to halt his speeding vehicle. The police justified their actions, harkening back to the horrific incident of July 14, 2016, when a Tunisian descendant rammed his truck into a crowd in Nice, causing 86 deaths and injuring 434 people.
The police's reasoning did not assuage public outrage. Nahel's mother expressed her pain and anger on France 5 TV, accusing the officer of racial bias and wanting to take her son's life. Interior Minister Gérald Darmanin found the police action unacceptable, and President Emmanuel Macron called Nahel's death "inexplicable, inexcusable". The officer involved was subsequently detained and charged with voluntary manslaughter.
France's Unrest: When Grief Morphs into Rage
In the following days, France found itself in a turmoil as riots erupted across the country. Protesters carried signs reading "the police kill," an explicit expression of their anger over perceived racial bias within the country's law enforcement. Government buildings were damaged, and civil unrest spread.
French officials responded by mobilizing over 40,000 police officers across the nation, arresting more than 2,000 people, and injuring over 500 police officers and gendarmes. Looting was reported in several cities, including Lyon, Marseille, and Grenoble. According to the Interior Ministry, more than 3,600 people were detained during the unrest, the majority of whom were teenagers.
Cultural Chasm and Political Divisions Fuel France's Unrest
As France grappled with its worst civil unrest in years, the political war between the left and right wings of the country intensified.
Leftist Take: Cries of Institutional Racism Reverberate Across the Republic:
Pointing fingers towards deep-seated institutional racism and the quick-trigger mindset of law enforcement, the leftist voices echoed loudly across the political spectrum. Olivier Faure, the leader of the Socialist Party, pointedly criticized the state's actions and declared, “Refusing to stop doesn’t give you a license to kill. All the children of the Republic have the right to justice.” Similarly, senior hard-left MP Mathilde Panot drew parallels to previous incidents and highlighted the disturbing money-making scheme, saying, "Killing a young North African in France in 2023 can earn you a lot of money.”
Right's Standpoint: Responsibility, Compliance, and Consequences:
Conversely, the right wing stood firm on their ground of law and order, voicing the necessity for compliance with the police. Jean Messiha, a far-right leader and former senior civil servant, countered the leftist sentiments by placing the responsibility for Nahel's death on the young man himself, his parents, and the justice system. He controversially stated, "If you don't obey the police, you're putting your finger in a spiral which, once again, can lead to tragedy. In this case, Nahel committed suicide, nothing more, nothing less.”
A Presidential Response to France's Unrest
President Macron faced heavy criticism for his handling of the situation. He condemned the violence and vowed to restore order and justice. Macron tasked the interior minister with maintaining a "massive" police presence and investigating Nahel's shooting. He also announced measures to address the root causes of the riots, such as improving socio-economic opportunities, fighting discrimination, and promoting dialogue between the police and communities.
Global Perspectives on the Unrest in France
The unrest in France caught the attention of the international community, prompting reactions from entities like the European Union (EU) and the United Nations (UN). The EU's justice commissioner, Didier Reynders, urged France to respect human rights and the rule of law. France, however, rejected his comments, stating that the EU had no business interfering in its internal affairs. The UN called for France to address deep-seated issues of racism and racial discrimination in law enforcement. Their spokesperson, Ravina Shamdasani, stressed the importance of peaceful assembly and encouraged the authorities to ensure that police force respects the principles of legality, necessity, proportionality, non-discrimination, precaution, and accountability.
SECTION 2: France and Europe: Immigration Deepening Cultural Chasm and Unrest
According to the 2021 census conducted by INSEE, immigrants constitute 10.3% of the French populace, marking a total of 7 million individuals.
Unrest Traced: Post-1950s Immigration in France and Europe
Migration has shaped Europe profoundly since World War II, driven by historical, political, economic, and humanitarian factors. Conflicts like the Arab Spring, Iraq Conflict, Syrian Civil War, War in Afghanistan, Somalian Civil War, and tensions between Ukraine and Russia have triggered substantial migration to Europe.
Migration to Europe since the 1950s can be divided into three periods:
1950s to 1973: Marked by Labour migration agreements and refugee migration, primarily from East to West.
1974 to 1989: Characterized by restrictions on migration in North-Western Europe due to the oil crisis, with family reunification becoming the primary migration route.
1990 to Present: Defined by increasing European Union control over migration and intra-European mobility, alongside rising populist, anti-immigration sentiment, and the need for integration and social cohesion.
Understanding this historical context is crucial to address present migration-related challenges, shaping Europe's demographic composition, societal fabric, and political landscape.
Demographic Shifts: Europe’s Growing Cultural Chasm
Over the last two decades, migration has significantly reshaped the demographic landscapes of Europe. As per Eurostat, in 2021, net migration in the EU saw 1.2 million people arrive from non-EU countries, while 0.2 million moved internally within the EU. Germany led EU countries in net migration with an increase of 312,735 individuals, followed by Spain and France. Among non-EU European countries, Russia experienced the highest net influx.
Migration Flow in the EU - 2021
Migration Type | Immigrants (million) | Emigrants (million) | Net Migration (million) |
Non-EU to EU | 2.3 | 1.1 | 1.2 |
Within EU | 1.4 | 1.2 | 0.2 |
Highest Net Migration in EU Member States - 2021
Country | Net Migration |
Germany | 312,735 |
Spain | 275,022 |
France | 174,000 |
Migration France
In France, the 2021 census by INSEE identified 7 million immigrants, 10.3% of its total population. Notably, around 32% of individuals under 60 had immigrant ancestry, with Algeria, Morocco, and Portugal being major origins.
France Immigration Census - 2021
Total Immigrants (million) | % of Total Population | Foreign Nationals (million) | Acquired French Citizenship (million) |
7 | 10.30% | 4.1 | 2.9 |
Migration Germany
Germany's 2022 census by Destatis revealed a foreign population of 13.4 million, 16.1% of its total population. The leading countries of origin were Turkey, Romania, and Poland. Furthermore, 20.8 million individuals were identified as having migration backgrounds.
Germany Immigration Census - 2022
Total Foreigners (million) | % of Total Population | Foreigners Born in Europe (million) | Foreigners Born in Asia (million) | Foreigners Born in Africa (million) |
13.4 | 16.10% | 9.3 | 2.9 | 0.7 |
In summary, Germany, Spain, France, and Russia have seen the highest immigration levels in Europe over the last two decades. The diverse origins of these immigrant populations emphasize Europe's multicultural fabric.
Immigrant-Host Dichotomy: Amplifying France & Germany’s Cultural difference
Immigrants Prospective:
Migrants are attracted to Germany and France due to existing family ties and social networks.
Robust economies in both countries present substantial economic opportunities and offer better job prospects.
Both Germany and France enjoy political stability, respect human rights, and uphold the rule of law, creating safe environments for immigrants.
The generous asylum policies of these nations act as a beacon for people seeking protection from crises in their home countries.
State/Countries Prospective:
Germany and France perceive their immigration policies as fulfilling a humanitarian and moral duty, aligned with international obligations.
Economic and demographic advantages are significant as immigrants fill labor shortages, contribute to taxes, create jobs, and help offset aging populations and shrinking workforces.
The cultural diversity brought by immigrants enriches society, fostering tolerance, mutual understanding, and social cohesion.
Despite these benefits, challenges remain such as integration issues, cultural differences, and occasional societal hostility towards immigrants, underscoring the complexity of the immigration issue.
Unrest in France: Dissecting the Impact of Immigration
Demographic Shifts: With 23.8 million non-EU citizens and 38 million people born outside the EU living within its borders as of 2023, immigration significantly shapes Europe's population. This shift has potential implications for the region's future demographic trends.
Economic Impacts: Immigration deeply impacts the labour market. On one hand, immigrants contribute to economic growth by filling workforce demand gaps, especially as they're more likely to be working-age. On the other hand, their presence can create competition and potentially displace native workers in low-wage sectors.
Fiscal Balance Effects: While immigrants contribute to public revenues through taxes and social contributions, they also receive public benefits and services. The net fiscal impact varies based on factors like age, skills, employment status, length of stay, and country-specific tax/welfare systems.
Cultural Changes: Immigration influences social and cultural diversity, enriching Europe's cultural landscape with various languages, religions, values, and traditions. However, it can also pose challenges for social cohesion and integration, especially with large cultural or socio-economic gaps between immigrants and natives. Discrimination or prejudice against immigrants can further compound these challenges.
Resistance Against Immigration: A Focus on Poland and Hungary
On June 29, 2023, Hungary and Poland expressed their disapproval towards the European Union's migration agreement by exercising their veto power (Source: AP News). The central European nations objected to the proposed arrangement that would penalize countries refusing to accommodate migrants, with a hefty charge of 20,000 euros per person. This event is representative of the hard-line anti-immigration stance increasingly adopted by certain EU nations.
Undeniably, the aftermath of immigration issues is echoing across Europe. Most recently, this led to the collapse of the Dutch government over proposed policies by Prime Minister Mark Rutte, resulting in his forced resignation. More on this critical issue coming soon. |
Immigrant Employment: An Unbalanced Equation
In the vast landscape of the European Union's labor market, non-EU citizens play a distinct role. According to the 2022 European Commission Report, amidst 189.7 million people aged 20-64, 8.84 million non-EU citizens were gainfully employed, representing a mere 4.7% of the total. However, the employment disparity becomes evident when comparing the employment rate of EU citizens at 74% with non-EU citizens at a significantly lower 59.1%. This underlines a clear imbalance in the employment of immigrants, raising questions about opportunities and economic integration.
EU vs Non-EU: Employment Disparity (2022)
| Total Population (20-64 years old) | Employed Population | Employment Rate (%) |
EU Citizens | 180.86 million | 133.84 million | 74 |
Non-EU Citizens | 8.84 million | 5.23 million | 59.1 |
From this data, we can identify some notable trends:
Non-EU citizens make up about 4.7% of the total population aged 20-64, but their employment rate is significantly lower (59.1%) than that of EU citizens (74%).
This employment disparity highlights a potential issue with the economic integration of non-EU citizens.
The overall employment rate across the EU for this age group (73.3%) is largely influenced by the employment rate of EU citizens, due to their majority share in the population.
SECTION 3: Triggers of Unrest: Racism & Terror in France & Europe
"When we win, we're all Germans. If we lose, then we are the Blacks, then the monkey comments come out”- Youssoufa Moukoko (German National Football Player)
Racism Incidents: An Unfortunate Recurrence
The past decade has seen a disturbing rise in racism across Europe, with individuals of African, Asian, Middle Eastern, Roma, or Jewish descent being the primary targets. These incidents range from verbal abuse and harassment to physical violence and hate crimes, with some linked to specific contexts like the refugee crisis, COVID-19 pandemic, Brexit referendum, and the Euro 2020 football tournament. Systemic discrimination also persists in sectors such as education, employment, housing, and healthcare.
Data from the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA) and the European Network Against Racism (ENAR) highlight the prevalence of racial harassment, hate speech, discrimination, and racially fueled violence. A poignant example is the 207 instances of racist abuse towards England's black players following the Euro 2020 final, demonstrating that such bigotry even permeates the world of sports.
These examples represent only a fraction of the incidents, many of which go unreported. The fight against racism requires robust efforts, including legal measures, awareness campaigns, education programs, anti-discrimination policies, and promoting intercultural dialogue. Recognition of the issue is the first step towards change.
Significant Terrorist Attacks in France and Germany (2015-2020)
Terrorism, particularly of Islamist extremist origin, has gravely affected France and Germany in recent years.
November 2015, Paris, France: A series of coordinated shootings and bombings occurred at various locations across Paris, including the Bataclan theatre, the Stade de France stadium, and several restaurants and bars. The attacks resulted in 130 deaths and over 400 injuries. The Islamic State (IS) claimed responsibility.
July 2016, Nice, France: On Bastille Day, a Tunisian man drove a truck into a crowd on the Promenade des Anglais in Nice, causing 86 fatalities and injuring over 400 people. The IS claimed responsibility.
December 2016, Berlin, Germany: A Tunisian man drove a truck into a Christmas market near the Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church in Berlin, resulting in 12 deaths and over 50 injuries. The IS claimed responsibility.
October-November 2020, France: A series of three Islamist terrorist attacks took place in France:
A teacher who had shown cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad during a lesson was beheaded by an 18-year-old Chechen refugee.
Three people were stabbed to death by a Tunisian migrant at the Notre-Dame de l’Assomption Basilica in Nice.
Three police officers were shot dead and another was injured by a man who had earlier killed his partner at their home in Saint-Just. The attacker later committed suicide.
These events underscore the severity of the terrorism threat in France and Germany, necessitating vigilance and international cooperation in prevention and response measures.
SECTION 4: Reflections on France’s Unrest: Key Takeaways
“We asked for workers. We got people instead.”― Max Frisch
Global Implications Stemming from France's Unrest
As the socio-political turmoil unfolds in France, it's clear that the implications of these events extend far beyond its borders. A crucial part of understanding this scenario involves examining the impact of capitalist ideologies, the futures of asylum seekers and migrants, and the anxieties of native citizens in countries experiencing significant demographic shifts.
The Capitalist Paradox: Demographic Shifts and France’s Unrest
Capitalist economies thrive on labor, and migrants often fill the demand for inexpensive, flexible workforces. Yet, this seemingly symbiotic relationship can lead to unexpected repercussions. The surge of immigration in countries like France and Germany has triggered dramatic demographic shifts, leading to socio-cultural tensions and unrest. The recent violence serves as a stark reminder that capitalism's pursuit of labor can have profound, unintended consequences.
Immigrant Crossroads: Insights into France Unrest
The climate of escalating tension and violence raises serious concerns for individuals seeking asylum or looking to migrate to more advanced countries. The incidents in France serve as a sobering illustration of potential hazards and hostility they might encounter. Furthermore, they underscore the need for a more humane and comprehensive approach to global migration policies that protect migrants' rights and ensure their safety.
Native Inhabitants' Unease: Addressing Concerns Amid Rapid Demographic Changes
The sudden influx of immigrants has also stirred anxieties among the native populations in host countries. These concerns often revolve around perceived threats to local demographics, culture, and economic stability. The recent unrest in France amplifies these fears, highlighting the need for more thoughtful integration policies and dialogues about multiculturalism that can foster understanding and unity in these changing societies.
Assertively speaking, the ripple effects of immigration matters across Europe have been profound and far-reaching. The latest incident that starkly underscores the ramifications of these issues is the dramatic collapse of the Dutch government. The bone of contention was the contentious new policies proposed by the Dutch Prime Minister, Mark Rutte. Facing unyielding opposition from his coalition, Rutte found himself backed into a corner and was ultimately forced to tender his resignation. The tumultuous political events in the Netherlands brought about by these immigration policies cannot be understated. Stay tuned as we delve into this crucial issue in more depth in our forthcoming articles.
Reference
bbc.com
newindianexpress.com
BBC News Report
timesnownews.com
Sky News
Migrant crisis: Migration to Europe explained in seven charts - BBC News
Migration and Immigrants in Europe: A Historical and Demographic Perspective | SpringerLink
Immigration to Europe - Wikipedia
Europe’s migrant crisis: The year that changed a continent - BBC News
"Germany: Immigration and Census Overview" - Wikipedia
"Birthplace & Citizenship Status of Foreign Population" - Destatis
"The Immigrant Background of 20.8 Million Germans" - DW
"France and Germany: A Comparative Study of Immigration" - Wikipedia
"Economic Indicators of France and Germany: A Comparison" - GDP, Inflation, CPI and Interest Rate Wikipedia Articles
"Minimum Wage Standards Across Europe" - Statistics Explained
"Country Profiles: Germany and France" - BBC News
"Europe's Asylum Landscape: Facts & Statistics" - UNHCR Europe & Statistics Explained
"Refugees in Europe: Why They Should Be Welcomed" - World Economic Forum
"An Explanation of Germany’s Refugee Policy" - DW
"Economic Dividends from Humanitarian Investments in Refugees" - Migration Policy Institute Europe
"Integration of Refugees: Economic Benefits and Costs" - Migration Policy Institute Europe, Bruegel, OECD
"The Influence of Immigration on Social Benefits and Cultural Diversity in Europe" - Migration Policy Institute, European Commission
"Racial Prejudice and Terrorism in Europe: An Analysis" - Wikipedia, Statista
"European Migration Statistics" - European Commission
"Historical & Demographic Perspectives on Migration in Europe" - SpringerLink
"Effects of Immigration on the Labour Market" - Migration Observatory
"The Economic Impact of Migration" - OECD
"Key Facts about Immigration" - Brookings
Racism and prejudice in Europe - Statistics & Facts | Statista
Racism in Europe - Wikipedia
Racism against black people in EU ‘widespread and entrenched’ - BBC
Being Black in the EU - European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights
ENAR Shadow Report: Racism & Discrimination in Employment in Europe (2015-2019)
Euro 2020 racist abuse - 11 people arrested - BBC News.
Europol, "Terrorism in the EU: terror attacks, deaths and arrests in 2020"
Wikipedia entries on each specific attack mentioned.
Underlining issues has to be realise by everyone to free the World from these vicious cycles
Underlying causes should be address first avoid such unrest in future..