“I have a message for all the founders in the country – don’t be a slave to these VCs. They act like the East India Company and make everyone a slave.”– Ashneer Grover.
Table of Contents
Global Venture Capital and the Indian Startup Landscape and Beyond: A Detailed Analysis.
Venture Capital Influence in the Evolving Indian Startup Landscape.
Venture Capitalists Reshaping Business Strategies in the Indian Startup Landscape.
Impact of Global Financial Crises on the Venture Capitalist-Driven Startup Landscape in India.
Caution for New Startups in Indian Landscape.
Conclusion.
Global Venture Capital and the Indian Startup Landscape and Beyond: A Detailed Analysis
In the modern business landscape, the emergence and influence of Global Venture Capital (VC) are undeniably profound. In particular, the Startup Ecosystem in India, known for its unique blend of traditional family-run businesses and dynamic startups, has witnessed a significant shift. Traditionally, businesses focused on maintaining profitability and sustainability, hallmarks of India's age-old business ethics. However, the introduction and rise of VC culture, guided by expansion and reach, have ushered in a radical transformation. With Venture Capitalist giants like Softbank, Y Combinator, Tiger Global, Sequoia Capital, and Accel leading the way, the shift in India's business culture is not just palpable but also setting the trend for startups around the world. This article delves into this intriguing paradigm shift, tracing its influence and impact on Indian startups and the global business ecosystem.
Venture Capital Influence in the Evolving Indian Startup Landscape
The Indian startup ecosystem, known for its innovation and resilience, has been experiencing a significant transformation over the past decade. This change has been predominantly driven by the influx of global Venture Capital (VC) firms that have sought promising opportunities within India's burgeoning startup scene.
Post liberalization, Indian businesses traditionally prioritized profitability, sustainability, and operated within closely-knit family partnerships imbued with a strong sense of trusteeship. These businesses had been instrumental in driving India's economic growth, developing communities, and providing employment opportunities for millions.
However, the advent of the global VC culture in early 2000s, it has instigated a significant shift from this traditional approach towards an expansionist model. The rise of global VC firms like Softbank, Y Combinator, Tiger Global, Sequoia Capital, and Accel within the Indian startup ecosystem has ushered in a new era.
These VC firms, leveraging substantial financial clout and strategic expertise, have provided startups with the necessary capital to rapidly scale their operations and reach. In return, they've extracted substantial influence over the strategic decisions of these companies, effectively reshaping the culture and goals of businesses within the Indian startup ecosystem.
The influx of VC investments has undoubtedly provided a shot in the arm for many startups. It has expedited their growth, increased their market reach, and boosted innovation. However, it's also worth noting that this paradigm shift has brought along with-it new challenges and increased competition.
This development has made an indelible impact on the startup ecosystem in India, forging a new business culture centered around rapid growth and expansion. As we move forward, understanding and navigating this VC-influenced landscape will be crucial for startups aiming for long-term success in India's dynamic market.
"Venture Capitalists Reshaping Business Strategies in the Indian Startup Landscape"
“It is important to remember that the investor is just another vendor"- Ashneer Grover.
As the global Venture Capitalist (VC) culture permeates the Indian startup ecosystem, the impact on business strategies has been profound. Global VC firms have fostered a shift in focus from profitability to rapid expansion and widespread reach, particularly in tech startups.
Take, for instance, BharatPe and Zomato. These startups, driven by VC funding, have aggressively expanded their markets and increased their reach without substantial consideration for the bottom line. The same is true for Grofers, now rebranded as Blinkit, an instant delivery service. Despite having no sustainable revenue generation model, it thrives on contemporary business models backed by these new-age VCs.
Aswath Damodaran, a noted financial guru, has also voiced concerns about the overvaluation of firms like Zomato in comparison to their industry peers. His critique underscores the potential risks and distortions in value associated with this VC-driven business model.
This shift isn't restricted to Indian startups alone. Uber, the global ride-hailing behemoth, also saw its co-founder, Travis Kalanick, grappling with the power wielded by VC firms. As Ashneer Grover points out in his book "Doglapan", VC firms often hold significant sway over the companies they invest in, influencing their decision-making process and even business strategy. In such cases, the founding members sometimes end up becoming puppets in the hands of the VC firms.
Such a scenario is indicative of the burgeoning influence of VC companies in the startup ecosystem in India and their capacity to transform traditional business practices. The dichotomy that now exists between the traditional Indian business ethos and the new-age VC-endorsed model necessitates a careful approach to navigate the startup ecosystem effectively.
Impact of Global Financial Crises on the Venture Capitalist-Driven Startup Landscape in India
A banker is a fellow who lends you his umbrella when the sun is shining, but wants it back the minute it begins to rain – Mark Twain
With the influx of global venture capitalists into the Indian startup ecosystem, the effects of international economic instability have become increasingly evident. The recent financial crises in Europe and the West have led to a significant decrease in startup funding in India. In fact, funding to Indian startups fell by a staggering 77% in February 2023 (source: Money Control), representing a chilling "funding winter."
One of the most significant financial shocks to hit the VC-driven startup ecosystem came with the Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) crisis. This crisis had far-reaching impacts on several Indian startups, including Bluestone, Carwale, InMobi, and Loyalty Rewardz. These companies had varying degrees of exposure to the SVB, which had become the default bank for a significant number of startups. For instance, 60% of YCombinator’s startups, many of which have Indian founders and operations in the US or India, were exposed to SVB. As a result, around 30% of these companies couldn't make payroll in the following month, putting their day-to-day operations in jeopardy. (source: Outlook)
In tandem with these international developments, home-grown issues have added to the challenges faced by Indian startups. For instance, the Indian startup ecosystem, which received $24 billion in 2022, saw a drop of 33% from the $37 billion it raised in 2021 (source: The Wire). As a consequence, many startups found themselves at a crossroads, struggling to strike a balance between growth and sustainability.
In such a complex and fluctuating financial environment, startups in India must remain vigilant. While the influence of global venture capitalists can bring in much-needed capital and innovation, it can also make these startups vulnerable to international financial shocks and trends. Therefore, understanding this global relevance and preparing for potential financial crises have become essential for startups operating in the VC-influenced ecosystem in India.
Caution for New Startups in Indian Landscape
You need to be absolutely unapologetic about working with family - Ashneer Grover
In the face of a rapidly evolving and sometimes tumultuous global financial environment, it's imperative for budding Indian entrepreneurs to navigate their ventures with a sense of discernment and balance. On one hand, there's the excitement of venturing into the unknown, backed by robust venture capitalist (VC) funding, where the emphasis is on expansion and market penetration. On the other hand, there's the well-trodden path of traditional Indian business practices, which emphasize profitability, sustainability, and a steadfast commitment to tried-and-true business models.
Taking heed from the advice of Ashneer Grover, co-founder and former managing director of BharatPe, entrepreneurs must not shy away from working with family. Grover's assertion to be "absolutely unapologetic about working with family" resonates profoundly in this context. Family partnerships, deeply rooted in the culture of trusteeship, have steered Indian businesses for generations, offering a compelling blueprint for sustainable success. The element of trust and mutual understanding that underlies such partnerships fosters resilience and longevity in business ventures.
Moreover, there's a wealth of knowledge and strategic acumen to be gleaned from traditional business houses that have weathered many economic seasons. These entities, with their focus on profitability and long-term sustainability, can serve as guiding posts for new-age entrepreneurs.
Lessons for Startup Landscape In India from the SVB crisis
A significant portion of Silicon Valley's startups depended on SVB for all their banking needs, from daily operations to payroll and hedging. Venture capitalists, particularly those from Y Combinator, maintained a close relationship with SVB, leading to an undeniable bias. Almost all startups backed by Y Combinator chose SVB as their preferred banking partner, highlighting the first red flag in this situation.
Startups in India, unfortunately, overlooked the age-old wisdom of capital diversification. As a result, they were severely impacted when the SVB crisis hit. Notably affected were Indian startups like Bluestone, Carwale, InMobi, and Loyalty Rewardz, all of which are backed by Y Combinator.
The importance of diversification is a lesson deeply ingrained in traditional Indian businesses, and startups must embrace this principle to build resilience against such crises. A measured approach that balances traditional business principles with VC-backed models could prove to be the most beneficial strategy for the burgeoning Indian Startup Ecosystem.
Conclusion
First make it work, then make it better. — Ajay Shrivastava, Knowlarity
As we chart the dynamic path of the Indian startup ecosystem, it's essential for new-age entrepreneurs to evaluate the merits of both traditional and trending VC-driven business models. There are invaluable lessons to be learnt from companies like Avenue Supermarts Limited (DMart). Founded by Radhakishan Damani in 2002, DMart thrives on a business model that mirrors traditional Indian systems - prioritize growing the bottom line before scaling. This strategy ensures that the foundation of your business is robust and capable of withstanding the trials of time and economic upheaval, as DMart did during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Embracing a balanced approach that combines the best of both worlds – the stability and sustainability of traditional business models and the scale and innovation of VC-backed models – can pave the way for sustainable success in India's vibrant startup ecosystem.
As the future of the startup ecosystem unfolds, the journey will undoubtedly be challenging but also ripe with opportunities. To successfully navigate this landscape, startups must learn, adapt, and evolve, informed by both the past and the future.
For more insights into economic trends and investment strategies, follow us @sdblognation. We delve into various facets of the business world, equipping you with knowledge to make informed decisions on your entrepreneurial journey.
Reference
1) Money Control: On slow down of funding in Startups in India.
2) Outlook: The macro and micro impact of SVB crisis on Indian Startups backed by VC closed to the Bank.
3) The Wire: Fall in the growth of Startups in India in FY21-22.
Comments